MetZelRio wrote:
1.) It seems in the shred community, we don't comment on YouTube very much for perhaps convenience sake?
I think people are paralyzed by choice, and stymied by not being "logged in." If I upload to YouTube, and post it on modified, then link to that on Facebook, on which of these platforms should people comment? They're the most likely to actually be logged in to Facebook. If they're actually logged in to Google (and thus logged into YouTube), should they comment directly on the video? Or, wait, are they logged into modified? Should they .... oh look kittens!!
I'm not saying that's good, but it's a reality. We are evermore pressed for time and are barraged with videos (of all stripes) to watch, and any barrier to commenting has become too much for most folks. 10 years ago, we didn't have these choices...
And all that is to say nothing of the psychology of not wanting to comment on anything any more (
particularly on youtube) because of the fear of being verbally abused in response. The internet is a scary place for a lot of folks, and I think people are more and more reluctant to publicly comment on
anything. I think the Facebook group seems the
least "public" and thus it's a kind of private haven in a wild west of openness. There's not ever been one flame war on the Facebook Group (that I've seen anyhow). YouTube has
homophobic language, and you don't have to be logged in to modified to see what anyone & everyone posts, but you can't comment unless you are, but what's my login/pass again?
I think I'm going to start tweeting my videos and link that to my Google + account
Is MySpace still a thing?
MetZelRio wrote:2.) The shred community doesn't utilize modified like they used to, therefore the comments/views aren't coming through there as much as they SHOULD BE.
I don't know. It's not as if I actually participated on modified for a good number of years there, but I did basically keep up on the much of the discussion. Not to diss anyone (it was a culture that took years to cause the erosion), but generally, in my opinion, the
quality of posting has actually gone up, and there's a much more positive, friendly vibe. Since I "took over" in 2010 I've not once moderated for content beyond technical shit. So maybe, Quality V. Quantity? I always thought that there was too much focus on politics and personalities (one of the reasons I 'left'), and now it just seems like people actually talk about, you know,
footbag. Even the "Discussion" forum is civil. I don't remember too many 20 paragraph-with-photos-and-video tournament write-ups in 2007.
MetZelRio wrote:
3.) I've noticed a good number of your videos are not authorized to be viewed on a mobile platform, and if this were changed, perhaps that many more would be able to view and comment.
This. This many times.
Jay7 does it (mobile) default to not being enabled for your account? Or do you turn it off for a reason. Because--and I can't recall a video of yours that does this in particular--but I can't count the number of videos that I
haven't watched because I couldn't see that shit on my phone. I'm not proud of that, really, but again, it's one of the realities of our current era.
MetZelRio wrote:
4.) Facebook, although I prefer modified, seems to be what everyone is taking part in. Comments and views up the wazoo, but the problem there is the veiws get logged on the actual video, but the comments aren't connected to it, so when some time passes and you go to look back at what people were saying.... it appears as though nobody said a dad blame thing.
This is a good point, and quite true, speaking to my above point about too much choice and the scattering effect.
I will say that there has been a definite surge in the use of modified recently. I actually stopped tracking the analytics a couple of weeks ago (a whole other post about that should happen...), but just judging by the number of posts each day, I'd say things aren't looking too bad
Despite the issues, I think
social login would boost posting/comments rather dramatically ...
Please allow me to also chime in, giving my praise on all video editors. I am still shredding footbags at the age of 38 because of you good people. Your inspiration is amazing. Thank you.
Jay7 I've shown my girlfriend 4 footbag videos: Vasek's semi's routine from 2002, Nick's routine from 2010,
your 300fps video, and Like Water 2. For many people, your video is the
only video I've shown them. It consistently blows people away for so many reasons. I wish I could record their reactions and show them to you...
Moderated for inappropriate language