qphox wrote:That was the only line I read because the rest of it looked too intimidating, and the bright blue link caught my attention."I have challenged Ryan Seath to a Sick 3 Challenge, my video is posted at http://shredvideoaddresshere.com"
I just wanted to let you know that the link is broken.
Sounds like a plan. A large plan, but a plan that could work.
You are right ... I was rethinking this, and 4 forums wouldn't be necessary. I think you'd only need 2 ... 1 where all the voting matchups for the all different skill divisions are setup, and one for general chit chat. It could also possibly all be done in one forum depending on how much traffic it is going to yield.david wrote:4 new forums is a bit much. perhaps one new one with 4 sub forums?
I'm not sure if I complete understand what you are saying, but if you are talking about my proposal, I didn't mean that every single competition would be in one stickied thread. Each individual competition would be in it's own stickied thread titled something like:Fu Xi wrote:I think a stickied thread would be too busy for all the competitions
so i agree a sub forum with each challenge as thread to makes it neater
Easily .. In most cases people will know what they are ... Ie. Jorden Moir = open, someone who just started playing = novice. For those in the middle, say for example yourself, you can choose to start competing in whatever skill level you think fits best, but you may be moved up or down accordingly as it goes on.Shredster wrote:I voted for open competition because how can we possibly divide people into close to equal segments??
I agree ... I've thought about it, and the number of people who could actively participate during a week would probably make one on competitions die out or stale after a while.ebo wrote:What about this form:
In case of an open challenge, we have a new subforum called
"Sick 3 competition" or something, and there will be a weekly
contest.
-each week will be represented in 3 seperate threads, one for each skill category, named by the actual calendar week.
This would look like this:
thread 1: "Week 45, Novice"
thread 2: "Week 45, Intermediate"
thread 3: "Week 45, Open"
- everyone posts his video in the thread it belongs.
- after 7 days have passed, a poll will be added to each of the threads, allowing the people to vote. The poll will be active for 2-3 days,
after that the winner is set.
- there will be a sticky thread with the rankings.
repeat for every new week. in case there are too few competitors,
we could extend the contests for another week or so.
ADDITIONALLY, there could be seperate challenges for two people who
want to battle themselves. But this could also be moved to the videos
section (as the video battles have been before).
Just kind of thought of something ...NuR wrote:This is a great idea !
Maby thats just brainfartin' from my end, but perhaps
the more experienced players would come up with a
plan to combine these two concepts...
) had a 9/1 lead. Then two or three people posted up saying the "1" combo was better and since then it's changed to a 10-5 lead. None of those 10 have felt the need to comment - presumably because either they are newbies who aren't really sure what they're talking about - or more likely they didn't feel it was necessary - anyway my point is that I think what people say can definitly have an impact on how people vote - and then people are voting on who wrote the most convincing post - not which combo looked the best to them. Anyway obviously I just sound bitter because nobody has spoken up for my combos and I'm biased - but I think in the future "no comments" is a good idea.That's a good point.Posi-Cole wrote:I still definitely think that all videos should be sent in to some moderator of the forum though, and then posted all at once by that person with the poll. This would just keep things much more organized and much neater in my opinion.
